National Institute of Justice National Institute of Justice. Research. Development. Evaluation. Office of Justice Programs
Crime Solutions.gov
Home  |  Help  |  Contact Us  |  Site Map   |  Glossary
Reliable Research. Real Results.
Additional Resources:

Program Profile: Parenting with Love and Limits®

Evidence Rating: Promising - More than one study Promising - More than one study

Date: This profile was posted on June 15, 2011

Program Summary

A program that combines group and family therapy to treat adolescents ages 10–18 with the primary diagnosis of oppositional defiant or conduct disorder. The program is rated Promising. Participants in the treatment group had significantly fewer offenses during the 12 months after program completion than the control group. There were some changes in caregiver attitudes and behaviors and improvement in child aggressive behavior. Communication between mothers and youths improved.

Program Description

Program Goals

Parenting with Love and Limits® (PLL) is designed for adolescent populations with the primary diagnosis of oppositional defiant or conduct disorder. PLL integrates group and family therapy into one system of care. Parents and teens learn specific skills in group therapy and then meet in individual family therapy to role-play and practice these new skills. This integration of group and family therapy enables parents to transfer these new skills to real-life situations.

 

Program Theory

PLL integrates principles of structural and strategic family therapy.

 

Program Components

During group therapy, teens and parents participate together in a small group, led by two facilitators. The group can include siblings and extended family. Each group consists of no more than 6 families and average between 12-15 people per group. Six 2-hour sessions are held weekly. Parents and teens meet together as a group for the first hour. During the second hour, the parents meet in one breakout group and the teens meet in another, with one facilitator leading each breakout. During family therapy, teens and parents meet individually with one of the group facilitators in between classes in an intensive 1- to 2-hour session to practice the new skills learned in group. Extensive role-plays are used along with the development of a typed-out, loophole-free contract. Four to six family therapy sessions are recommended for low- to moderate-risk adolescents and up to 20 sessions for moderate- to high-risk offenders within a residential, outpatient, or home-based setting.

Program Activities

The PLL program consists of six group therapy sessions plus four or more family therapy sessions, as shown below:

 

  • Group Session 1. Understanding Why Your Teen Misbehaves: Parents learn why their teen commits acts of parent abuse. Parents and teens go into their respective breakout groups to vent their feelings.  
  • Group Session 2. Button-Pushing: Parents learn how their teen pushes their "hot buttons" (whining, disgusted look, swearing, etc.), and teens learn how parents push theirs (lecturing, criticizing, talking in chapters, etc.).

First family session. Parents and teens meet individually to practice anti–button-pushing strategies.

 

  • Group Session 3. Ironclad Contracting: Parents learn how and why their old methods of contracting have failed, as well as the steps to assemble a contract that works. Teens meet in their breakout groups to help write their own contract.

Second family session. Parents and teens meet individually to create their own contract.

 

  • Group Session 4. Troubleshooting: Parents learn how teens have a special ability called “enhanced social perception” to think two steps ahead.

Third family session. Parents and teens meet individually to review their contracts and troubleshoot any loopholes. Extensive role-plays are used to practice delivery of rewards and consequences.

 

  • Group Session 5. Stopping the Seven Aces: Parents choose creative consequences to stop the seven “aces” of the youth who doesn’t have a serious psychological problem, but is acting out of control: disrespect, ditching or failing school, running away, drugs or alcohol, sexual promiscuity, violence, and threats of suicide.  

Fourth family session. Parents and teens meet individually to review their progress.

 

  • Group Session 6. Reclaiming Lost Love: Parents learn to understand how conflict hinders the parent–child relationship and strategies to repair it.  
Fifth family session and beyond, as needed. Parents and teens begin to solidify nurturance and to address any underlying family dysfunction.

Evaluation Outcomes

top border

Study 1

Recidivism Rates

Sells and colleagues (forthcoming) found that participants in the Parenting with Love and Limits® (PLL) treatment group had significantly fewer offenses during the 12 months after program completion than the control group (23.5 percent for PLL attendees, compared with 59.0 percent for control group).

 

Changes in Caregiver Attitudes and Behaviors

Three of the five constructs of the caregiver survey were significantly improved from baseline to postprogram for the PLL group, compared with the control group. The three constructs were parental resilience, social support, and problem solving and communication.

 

Changes in Adolescent Attitudes and Behaviors

There was no significant improvement on the total youth survey score from baseline to postprogram between the PLL group when compared with the control group, though there was a trend (p=0.063). Two of the 13 constructs, however, did result in significant improvements: high value on helping others and social competencies. The Positive Perception of Self and Others construct neared significance. Changes on the other 10 constructs were not significant.

 

Study 2

Recidivism Rates

Sells, Winokur-Early, and Smith (2011) found that participants in the PLL treatment group had fewer offenses during the 12 months after program completion than the control group (16 percent for PLL attendees, compared with 55 percent for the control group). Additionally, juveniles in the treatment group spent a total of 72 days in detention, while juveniles in the control group spent 543 days in detention.

 

Child Behavior

On all but two subscales, the PLL group participants improved significantly more than the control group participants. Moreover, the two subscales on which there were no significant differences between the groups measured concerns (somatic problems and delusional thinking) that are not expected outcomes for the PLL intervention. The most significant difference between the groups was on the aggressive subscale, with the control group scores increasing from baseline to postprogram and the PLL group decreasing during the same time period.

 

Readiness for Change—Adolescents

Of the four readiness areas measured, only the Action subscale was significantly higher at posttest for the PLL group than for the control group, though it is unclear whether the youths rated this subscale high because they were ready for change or they thought their parents should change.

 

Readiness for Change—Caregivers

Results for PLL group caregivers suggest that these respondents were transitioning from the precontemplation stage to advanced stages of readiness for change. The group mean of PLL group caregivers increased 9 points in the Ready for Action subscale, compared with the group mean for the control group caregivers which decreased at posttest.

 

Communication Between Mothers and Youths

Adolescents in the PLL group reported that communication with their mothers was significantly improved, compared with the reports of youths in the control group. Mothers in the PLL group also reported improved communication with their youths, compared with mothers in the control group.

bottom border

Evaluation Methodology

top border

Study 1

Sells and colleagues (forthcoming) used a quasi-experimental, two-group design to evaluate Parenting with Love and Limits® (PLL). The sample consisted of youths in the juvenile justice system who responded to a referral by their probation officer. Of the 105 families who agreed to participate, 67 completed the PLL program and 38 did not finish all six modules. The average length of participation in the program was 36 days. Retention rate was 64 percent, a rate considered high given that participants were not court-ordered to attend the program.

 

The average age of adolescents was 16 years, with a range of 11 to 17 years. All participants were diagnosed with either oppositional defiant or conduct disorder and were currently on probation through juvenile court. The 65 participants of the control group were also under court supervision and were matched with the intervention group by the county court administrator on similar family structure, age, race, and gender. Study participants were primarily Hispanic (38.1 percent), white (36.1 percent), and African American (21.9 percent). Males accounted for 67.1 percent of the participants. Family composition of the group included single-parent families (65.8 percent), dual families (31.6 percent), and kinship care families or youths raised by extended family members (2.6 percent).

 

Outcome measures consisted of:

 

·         Recidivism (defined as at least one rearrest for a status or delinquent offence within 12 months following completion of PLL)

·         Changes in attitudes and behaviors of parents measured with the survey Prevention and Early Intervention Protective Factor Survey for Caregivers

·         Changes in attitudes and behaviors of adolescents measured with the survey Prevention and Early Intervention Protective Factor Survey for Youth

 

Data was collected immediately before the first PLL group meeting and immediately following the last group meeting. Recidivism data for both groups was through juvenile court records by the court administrator at the local juvenile court 12 months after the completion of the parenting group. Data was analyzed using paired t–tests.

 

Study 2

Sells, Winokur-Early, and Smith (2011) used an experimental design with random assignment of youths within the juvenile court system. Youths who were diagnosed with oppositional defiant or conduct disorder were eligible to participate. A total of 38 adolescents adjudicated for a delinquent offense and disposed to probation through the juvenile court were matched on type of offense, gender, age, and socioeconomic status and then randomly assigned to a PLL treatment group and a control group that received customary probation services. The large majority of youths were African American (82 percent), along with 12 percent white, and 1 percent Hispanic. Fifty-seven percent of the adolescents were male. The youths committed a variety of crimes, with shoplifting the most commonly occurring offense. No information is given on the equivalence of the groups on demographic and criminal offenses.

The treatment group received the 6-week PLL program in small groups of no more than 12 people per therapy group during six 2-hour classes. The control group received parole services and other services such as outpatient counseling or community service.

 

The measures used in the study included the Child Behavior Checklist, the Index of Parental Attitudes, the Parent Adolescent Communication Scale, and the Parent Readiness Scale. Both the parents and adolescents in the treatment group received the pretest measures in an interview before the treatment and again immediately following the final PLL class.

bottom border

Cost

top border
Costs vary based on population to be served and the total number of families to be served annually. Please contact Parenting with Love and Limits® for specific cost information.
bottom border

Implementation Information

top border

In both group and family therapy, counselors are provided with detailed treatment manuals and the parents and teenagers are provided with workbooks and a study guide.

bottom border

Evidence-Base (Studies Reviewed)

top border
These sources were used in the development of the program profile:

Study 1
Sells, Scott P., Kelly J. Stepura, Kristin Winokur-Early, and Stephanie Bontrager Ryon. (Forthcoming.) “Parenting with Love and Limits: A Program for Resistant Parents and Adolescents with Severe Behavioral Problems.” Submitted for publication.

Study 2
Sells, Scott P., Kristin Winokur-Early, and Thomas E. Smith. 2011. “Reducing Adolescent Oppositional and Conduct Disorders: An Experimental Design Using Parenting with Love and Limits.” Professional Issues in Criminal Justice 6(3).
bottom border

Additional References

top border
These sources were used in the development of the program profile:

Sells, Scott P. 2001. Parenting Your Out-of-Control Teenager. New York, N.Y.: St. Martin’s Press.

Sells, Scott P., Thomas Edward Smith, and Jeffrey Rodman. 2003. “Reducing Adolescent Substance Abuse and Delinquency: Pilot Research of a Family-Oriented Psycho-Education Curriculum.” Journal of Child and Adolescent Substance Abuse 15(4):105–15.

Winkour, Kristin. 2010. Parenting With Love and Limits® (PLL) Research Evaluation: 2009–10 Outcomes. Tallahassee, Fla.: Justice Research Center.

Winkour, Kristin. 2010. Parenting With Love and Limits (PLL) Champaign County, Ill., Mental Health Board Research Evaluation: 2009–10 Outcomes. Tallahassee, Fla.: Justice Research Center.

Winokur Early, Kristin, Steven F. Chapman, and Gregory A. Hand. 2013. “Family-Focused Juvenile Reentry Services: A Quasi-Experimental Design Evaluation of Recidivism Outcomes.” OJJDP Journal of Juvenile Justice 2(2):1–22. (This study was reviewed but did not meet Crime Solutions' criteria for inclusion in the overall program rating.)
bottom border


Program Snapshot

Age: 11 - 17

Gender: Both

Race/Ethnicity: Black, Hispanic, White

Geography: Suburban, Urban

Setting (Delivery): Other Community Setting

Program Type: Conflict Resolution/Interpersonal Skills, Family Therapy, Group Therapy, Parent Training

Targeted Population: Status Offenders, Truants/Dropouts, Young Offenders, Families

Current Program Status: Active

Listed by Other Directories: Model Programs Guide, National Registry of Evidence-based Programs and Practices, Promising Practices Network

Program Developer:
Scott P. Sells
CEO
Savannah Family Institute, Inc.
P.O. Box 30381
Savannah GA 31410-0381
Phone: 866.735.9525
Fax: 866.512.2067
Website
Email

Program Director:
Parenting with Love and Limits
P.O. Box 30381
Savannah GA 31410-0381
Phone: 866.735.9525
Fax: 866.512.2067
Website